Is IT Accountable for Corporate Shenanigans?

[article]
Summary:

We have the potential in our professions to encounter unethical and illegal uses of technology and data. In this column, Eileen Strider describes a situation in which you suspect a dishonest use of information in a system you're testing. What do you do?

Many information technology trade journals are publishing articles about the recent corporate accounting shenanigans. They are asking interesting questions about the role of IT executives, managers, and professionals in these matters. Some write that Chief Information Officers (CIOs) should be held accountable for how financial information is recorded and reported. I think this could get you fired, especially if the CIO reports to the Chief Financial Officer, who may order you in not-so-nice words to keep your nose out of his job. Having the word "information" in your title doesn't appoint you the "information police." On the other hand, what is an IT professional's responsibility when it comes to the use of technologies? I'm sure others' opinions will differ widely from my own. I do, however, consider this an important topic for us to debate as quality assurance and testing professionals.

Here's a hypothetical scenario. You are regression testing the next release of your company's general ledger system when you discover a change in how the system handles special journal entries. The previous release required the comments field to be completed explaining the reason for the journal entry—this is standard accounting practice. The previous release also logged the user ID of the person submitting the journal entry. But the new version you are testing allows you to complete a journal entry with no explanation in the comment field and the logging function seems to have been disabled. You probably are not a CPA; however, you've tested this system enough in the past to recognize that this is not the way journal entries are typically processed. Your suspicion is raised by the results of your testing. What do you do?

You could pretend you didn't notice and do nothing. You could record this as a bug as you do any other bug. You could bring it to your manager's attention. You could talk to an auditor about it. You could ask the finance manager responsible for the general ledger about this change in the handling of journal entries. You could bring it to the controller's attention or the CFO's attention. You could decide that your company is behaving unethically and quit before they end up on the front page of the newspaper.

In keeping with my own values, I would feel obligated to talk to someone in management about this. I would start with the generous interpretation that this change was an unintended mistake. I would try to find out if this is the case. If I find out otherwise or am stonewalled, then I have to make another decision about whether to escalate my concerns and, if so, to whom. I think it's not only fair but also important to assess the impact on myself of escalating my concern. If I escalate the issue and after all good faith attempts, I am convinced that this was an intentional change to provide a way to move funds around while hiding the reasons and obscuring the audit trail, I would have a really big decision to make about staying with the company or leaving.

About the author

Eileen Strider's picture Eileen Strider

Eileen Strider facilitates project reviews, project retrospectives, and IT organization assessments based on her experience as a developer, software project manager, IT manager, and Chief Information Officer. She occasionally fills in as a temporary CIO. With her partner, Wayne Strider, she leads the annual Strider & Cline Leaders' Forum. See www.striderandcline.com/ or send email to eileenstrider@worldnet.att.net.
 

StickyMinds is one of the growing communities of the TechWell network.

Featuring fresh, insightful stories, TechWell.com is the place to go for what is happening in software development and delivery.  Join the conversation now!

Upcoming Events

Nov 09
Nov 09
Apr 13
May 03